PURPOSE: To compare long-term patient-reported outcomes (PROs) between patients with and without critical humeral bone loss (CHBL) and to compare long-term PROs among patients with CHBL who underwent arthroscopic Bankart repair (ABR) alone versus those who received a remplissage augmentation (ABR + R).
METHODS: A retrospective review included patients aged 13 to 50 years who underwent ABR or ABR + R for anterior shoulder instability from 2007 to 2023. Exclusion criteria included <1-year follow-up, >20% glenoid bone loss, off-track Hill-Sachs lesion, concomitant pathology, or revision surgery. CHBL was defined as humeral head defect extension below the 90° equator. Western Ontario Shoulder Index, pain Visual Analog Scale, and Subjective Shoulder Value were collected at the final follow-up. PROs and recurrence rates were compared between cohorts and within the CHBL subgroup.
RESULTS: Three hundred eighty-four patients were included (mean age 23 ± 9 years (range: 13-49), 78% men), of which 99 (26%) were successfully contacted for PROs: 129 (34%) with CHBL and 255 (66%) without CHBL. The CHBL cohort was older (25 vs 22 years, P < .01) and had smaller distance to dislocation (9 vs 13 mm, P < .01). Recurrent instability rates were comparable overall (22% vs 15%, P = .08), but, within the CHBL cohort, recurrence was significantly lower after ABR + R than ABR alone (9% vs 32%, P < .01). Ninety-nine patients (26%) (41 CHBL, 58 non-CHBL) completed PROs at a mean follow-up of 7.3 years (range: 1.9-14.4), with no significant differences in Western Ontario Shoulder Index, pain Visual Analog Scale, Subjective Shoulder Value, or recurrent instability between groups (all P > .05). In a multivariable linear regression, only recurrent instability was an independent predictor of inferior PROs; the presence of CHBL was not an independent predictor. Among CHBL patients, PROs were similar between ABR and ABR + R.
CONCLUSIONS: Patients with CHBL had similar long-term PROs to those without CHBL after ABR or ABR + R at a minimum follow-up of 1 year. Furthermore, the addition of remplissage was found to be associated with a reduced rate of recurrent anterior shoulder instability in patients with CHBL.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, retrospective cohort study.